Roofing Material Comparison Guide: Find the Best Fit for Your Home
Choosing the right roofing material is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a homeowner. Your roof doesn’t just protect your home from the elements, it defines your home’s look, energy efficiency, and long-term maintenance costs. With so many options available, it can feel overwhelming to decide which one is best.
At
Eyles Contracting Inc.., we’ve worked with every type of roofing material, from asphalt roof shingles to slate roofing, cedar shake roofing, rubber roofing, and metal roofing. As a
GAF Master Elite Contractor and
CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, we have the expertise to guide you in choosing the best material for your home or business. Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of each option to help you make the right choice for your New England home.
Asphalt Shingles
Pros:
- Affordable and widely available
- Easy to install and repair
- Many color and style options
- Class A fire-rated and weather-resistant
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan compared to other roofing materials (around 20–30 years)
- More susceptible to damage in extreme conditions
Best for: Homeowners looking for a cost-effective, versatile option that balances performance with style. Asphalt shingles are the most common material used in
roof replacement projects due to their balance of cost and durability.
Slate
Pros:
- Extremely durable (can last 75-100 years)
- Timeless, elegant appearance
- Fireproof and highly weather-resistant
Cons:
- High upfront cost
- Heavy weight may require additional roof reinforcement
- Repairs can be complex and require skilled installers
Best for: Historic homes or homeowners seeking long-term durability and a classic, upscale look. A slate roof is an investment, but when installed by experienced
roofing contractors, it can last generations.
Cedar Shake
Pros:
- Natural, rustic appearance
- Provides natural insulation and energy efficiency
- Can last 30-50 years with proper care
Cons:
- Requires regular maintenance to prevent moss, mold, and decay
- More expensive than asphalt shingles
- Less fire-resistant unless treated
Best for: Homeowners who love the charm of natural materials and are willing to invest in ongoing upkeep. A
professionally installed cedar shake roof brings unmatched character to New England homes.
Rubber (EPDM)
Pros:
- Seamless and highly water-resistant
- Economical for flat or low-slope roofs
- UV- and fire-resistant
- Energy-efficient with insulating properties
Cons:
- Limited style/color options (often black or white)
- Less traditional appearance for residential roofs
Best for: Flat or low-slope
residential additions, garages, and
commercial buildings needing reliable, low-maintenance protection. Rubber roofing is a cost-effective option for preventing roof damage on large surface areas.
Metal
Pros:
- Long lifespan (40-70 years)
- Lightweight and strong
- Energy-efficient by reflecting solar heat
- Many modern colors and styles available
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost than asphalt
- Can be noisy in heavy rain or hail (though underlayment reduces this)
- May dent from large hail or falling branches
Best for: Homeowners seeking a sleek, modern look or those who prioritize durability and energy efficiency. A metal roof can be an excellent long-term investment with professional roofing installation.
Choosing the Right Material for Rour Home
In New England, where homes face snow, ice, high winds, and seasonal temperature swings, durability is a must. Consider these factors when choosing:
- Budget: Asphalt shingles offer affordability, while slate and metal are higher upfront investments with longer lifespans. The cost of roof replacement will vary based on your choice of material.
- Style: Match your roofing choice to your home’s architectural character. Slate and cedar shake look beautiful on traditional homes, while metal and architectural shingles work well with modern designs.
- Maintenance: If you want a low-maintenance option, asphalt, rubber, and metal are your best bet. Cedar, on the other hand, requires the most upkeep to protect against moss, mold, and weathering.
- Longevity: Consider how long you plan to live in your home. Slate or metal may be the best investment if you’re looking for decades of durability.
Work with Trusted Roofing Professionals
When it comes to choosing the right roofing material, expert guidance makes all the difference. At
Eyles Contracting Inc., we bring decades of experience to every project, helping homeowners and businesses select the best roofing system for their needs. No matter the material, our team of certified professionals delivers
expert roofing installation with detail-focused craftsmanship. Don’t leave your roof to chance.
Contact us today for a free project estimate and work with a trusted roofer who can handle every aspect of your roof replacement with care and precision.
